Social Media and the grammar playground

Friday, July 31, 2009 by Susan Kent
I heard a discussion recently that really made me think (and I do everything I can to avoid that!). It was like having two good friends angry at each other, both with valid points. So it left me feeling torn...

The discussion was about social media, progressive thought, and professional representation. One party thought content ruled the day, and that the occasional word omission, misspelling, and "make up a word if you need to" line of thinking is progressive and powerful - and people who feel grammatical astuteness and spelling perfection are a must are archaic.

The other party feels writing as though you didn't pass 8th grade english is childish, ignorant, and misplaced in the professional world. And arguably, it depends on what professional world you are in. But the parties involved feel in most cases, they are right. Maybe they are both wrong. 

See, I was an English major. No misspelling, word omission, or punctuation error gets by me. I don't always take the time to correct them, but I always notice them, particularly in professional documents. But I get that not all people find those areas important, that sometimes the content and the attitude of the material far outweighs the need for proper comma usage. So who's right? Do you form impressions of people/products based on their command of the English language? Would you forgive word omissions and other errors when evaluating candidates if their content was great, or would you dismiss even the best candidate if you saw mistakes in their career portfolio? I think the real deal breaker is who is READING the content, not who is writing it. And by the way, those were not rhetorical questions...I'd love to hear your thoughts. 

So my point today is that even if you don't place a high level of value on grammatical perfection, the person who reads your professional portfolio through CS might, so take a moment to proofread.  Class dismissed.

Comments for Social Media and the grammar playground

Monday, August 17, 2009 by Will at virtualjobcoach.com:
I can't spell, really - can't. But I can use spell-check with gets about 99% of my errors. I feel that spelling mistakes are for small minds, unless, of course, you are interviewing for a copy-edit job. I haven't really seen any data that shows a causal relationship between spelling and productivity or intelligence. Yes, it can be an indicator to attention to detail, but beyond that, I am more concerned with the content (book by its cover anyone)
Monday, February 15, 2010 by PiperXt29:
I do not think that every student all over the world has a passion of college essay composing! However, students that do not have writing skills should use help of famous comparison essay service and be happy with a success.
Monday, February 15, 2010 by Bonnie:
I am like Susan in that I don't catch all of my errors, but as an HR manager I look for clean copy. Yes, the content is important, but do I want an employee that may send out work to clients with errors? It doesn't speak highly of the personal responsibility for the finished product.

Leave a comment





Captcha